Why is a Scion xD base model better then a Kia Soul base model?

[Bob]

Hello, I was wondering if you could tell me why the Scion xD base model is better then the comparable Kia soul base model in your opinion. thanks.

[Howard L]

In the recent Consumer Reports auto issue the Soul scored a bit better than the Scion in their evaluation, 68 to 60. Details are in the issue which you can probably find in your library. The Scion was recommended because the XD has established an excellent reliability history. The Soul the was not recommended because it's too new to predict how it will hold up.

Here is there summary.

The tall Soul packs a lot of room and equipment into a small, inexpensive car. It has very easy access, abundant headroom, and a surprisingly spacious rear seat. The 2.0-liter engine brings average acceleration and 25 mpg overall, which isn't anything special. Expect a noisy interior and a stiff ride. Handling is fairly nimble and secure with standard electronic stability control. Controls are simple but interior fit and finish is basic. Big windows allow very good front and side visibility, but thick rear roof pillars create rear blind zones. Crash-test results are impressive.

The xD is a boxier version of the Toyota Yaris. The ride suffers from short, jumpy motions, and the highway ride feels jittery. The 1.8-liter, four-cylinder engine delivers adequate performance but is miserly with fuel. We averaged 29 mpg overall with the automatic and 34 with the manual. The cabin is noisy and the driving position is awkward, but some taller drivers found the seat cushion too short. The front seats are comfortable enough for people who fit them. The rear has plenty of room for such a small car and cabin access is easy. The xD has a lot of standard features for its low price. Stability control is standard for 2010.